ok I'll play, though I'm a newb to a lot of new school parts. Here's my take. Keep in mind I'm a bigger dude so consider my weight. I don't give 10's unless it's holy grail i.e. custom made lol so 9-9.5 is like a 10 for me.
Sick Child Metro -
9.5 - First new school Flat Frame in 10yrs. Best frame I've ever had where it felt super balanced (weight distro) and zero flex. I've never had a more solid feeling frame. Add to that built in the USA (matters not to some) clean welds, and the personal touch from one super cool dude and you've got a wiener...err winner. In addition, mines got mounts (Thx Ed!)
I'll also add the Quamen Mobile Arms (hopefully it's safe to remention these) -
9. I can't think of one bad thing to say on these. Zero flex also and for the same reasons above (minus the custom personal aspect) I gotta swear by these. In fact I don't even want to mess around with anything else. My 2nd build will have these. I'd give them a 9.5 but they are cranks, so in an unbiased true response - I give them a 9. Which actually kinda is a bias, cause I'm holding my lack of wow against a really solid part. Alright, stfu Ray it's .5 diff and your newb opinion eats a d!ck anyhow
ok moving on lol
Revenge Brakes -
8.5 - Again super solid and the best brake I've ever tried. Admitedly (sp?) I've had little experience w new school brakes other than the Evo II, and 990's. I have a set of Fly's (potentially for sale if anyone is interested) I've never set up so those could be even better. I'd give them a higher rating, but price comes to mind (which I don't mind paying for a solid part) and weight (again not that I care, but I know some do so in fairness I'll rate appropriately)
For my dreaded 4th (Sorry Dave, musta been blitzed writing this
) I'll go with G Sport Rims -
9.5 - First off I love the engineering behind the rim. I dig the cross lacing and I've got ridiculous respect for good ol G's sick engineering skillZ (bowstaff skills, numchuk skills etc lol) Add a G Sport Hub (I've got the monkey) and that's one super solid wheel in my humble opinion. I'm comparing this to some of the grails of yester year (Araya 7x's, Peregrine Super HP Pro's)
Again, as a disclaimer I'll say this is my first new school build and I tried to pick the most solid parts I could, cost not withstanding, and parts that I sincerely liked after researching. Overall, I can't say one bad thing about my choices and it's easily the best bike (quality) I've ever owned, let alone built. So some could perceive that as bias, but I've tried to be super fair in my review. Feel free to slag me all you want lol but I'm sincerely legit stoked on all these parts and my bike overall. These weren't just inflated fan boy ratings. Cheers boyos!